I went back and forth on whether to order the Class-1 (20mph) or the HS Class-3 (28mph) model.
The primary factors in my decision to go with the Class-1 bike came down to:
- Being able to legally ride it in more places. (some parks and trails restrict you to Class-1 bikes)
- The variable assist eMTB mode on the CX motor. (which is not available on the Bosch Speed motors)
The eMTB mode increases assistance automatically as you press harder on the pedals.
And with my bad knees, the eMTB mode just felt much better on my knees versus needing to think about changing both the assistance level and gear position while test riding models with & without the eMTB mode.
It gave me one less item to deal with while riding variable terrain or while stopping for intersections.
However, those test rides were only a couple of miles each,
and after a couple of 20-30 mile days on my new Class-1 Homage, I am now wondering if I made the correct choice.
My moving average speed for those rides have been around 15-17mph, which is pushing close to the assistance limit of 20mph on this bike.
I am now wondering if I am going to be satisfied with the lower speed assistance long-term?
My previous (and first) e-bike is a Raleigh Talus with a 250 watt & 60N-m rear hub motor and torque sensing, with a maximum assist level of 100% in Turbo mode.
View attachment 85596
The new Homage offers 85N-m of torque and up to 340% boost in Turbo, or variable 140-340% assistance while in eMTB mode which is where I leave it most of the time.
Even in just the second assist level (Tour) the Bosch motor is giving 140% boost, which is more than the Raleigh offers when cranked all the way up.
Not to mention the fact that the power is being produced by the Homage is at the crank, which benefits from gearing reduction for additional torque at the rear wheel when climbing the numerous hills here in southeast Wisconsin.
View attachment 85597
The eMBT mode is very nice and natural feeling, requiring less fiddling with the power level for hills, but does not give the same feeling of assistance that comes with the fixed power levels. I KNOW that it is helping out when in eMTB mode, but you do not get the same sense of the motor pulling you along like when switching the bike into Turbo for a long hill.
Not to mention, that both the standard (20mph) Homage and the HS (28mph) model both use the same primary gearing on the belt drive, meaning that I reach the power cutoff threshold of 20mph while spinning the pedals at just over 80rpm in 10th gear.
Rendering the top 4 gears of my Rolhoff hub as virtually unusable unless going downhill; which I usually use for coasting/resting anyway.
If I had it to do over again, I might be tempted to go with the HS model and forgo the eMTB mode.
But I do enjoy letting the bike automatically manage the assistance level, which gives one less thing to think about for all but the steepest & longest hills (when I switch to Turbo).
Or, I just need to adjust my attitude when riding to not push so hard (which my knees would probably appreciate), and to focus more on enjoying the ride rather than going as fast as possible...
What I REALLY wanted was for Bosch to offer the eMTB mode in their Speed motors.
But in contacting both R&M and Bosch before ordering, they both confirmed that is not possible currently, and that Bosch has no plans to offer that combination in the future to differentiate the two motors. Which I understand from their perspective, but was not the answer I was hoping for.
I just need to keep reminding myself that this bike was purchased to get me back out into nature, not for commuting.
I do not NEED to go faster than what it offers.
As always, YMMV.