Mr. Coffee
Well-Known Member
- Region
- USA
- City
- A Demented Corner of the North Cascades
A guy named Marx beat him to it by 150 years.I bet my Fidelity guy could offer a solution.
If you had the government making investments in private securities how exactly would that work? Who would decide what securities to buy and which ones to sell? Who would decide when those were bought and sold? Also, if the securities are shares they come with voting rights, so the government would have votes and probably seats on the board.
You also get kind of stuck because that would be a very large portfolio. You'd obviously want transparency around its management. Except when you didn't want it -- e.g. because if you gave out advance information about your intentions to buy or sell certain classes of assets you'd make the markets go crazy. Well, crazier.
The whole idea is a demonstrably bad one. We have lots of experience in how well it works and all of it is ugly.