Hi,
I'm new to forum but I've read all of this thread, great info and thanks. I have an ex-demo Trance E+1 Pro MY2020 with RideControl One, and want to get rid of the 25kph 'wall'. This thread and my research have whittled things down to either the VOLspeed, or Speedbox. My reasons are: ....... the installation instructions (found on the web) relating to a Bikespeed RS option suggest you have problems when using Auto mode with RCOne, plus its not really clear how you use the RCOne, and the Giant app to set it up. I liked the simplicity of fitting, AND removing the Planet 3, AND its price. But according to Alex, (great communications by the way ) due to the etracker hubs, and as my axle removes from the break rotor side I need to change the end cap so the planet 3 gizmo fits. This involves taking the cassette off to get to the end cap, which is then none standard, plus it needs extra tooling around and then loctite to replace etc etc. So its not a quick method to remove should I need to revert the bike back to 'normal'. I don't like the Badass option as I would have to bodge-up a spoke magnet and move the sensor from inside the chain stay etc. etc So, its narrowed down to VOLspeed or Speedbox - both of which require the motor to be 'dropped', and the wires to be fiddled to fit it all back inside, though its seems the latest version of both now have a smaller 'black-box' , which should make it a bit easier. So there's not much difference in their installation.
Many of you must have done the same research, read this thread and then made your decision and fitted one or the other.
So what did you decided, and what's been your experience with either of them - particularly in relation to my specific bike with RCOne. It seems the RCOne may be an issue in initial setting-up and then using either device. Thanks in advance.