Ebikebuilderyt
New Member
- Region
- USA
So what size is your axle that you found it risky on? 12mm? How would you feel if it were a 14mm axle? No concerns? Or is it also the gears that are a worry for regen?
Perhaps DD is the way to go for full regen? Maybe this is why Grin removed the option to weld the stator on their Bafang motors this past year?
I also wonder how Engwie the Engine Pro 2.0 is faring with their regen implementation with their customers? I don't think they have a torque arm on it right? That's the bike that originally started me down this track once I'd heard it existed. But now I'm glad I didn't order it as it has some limitations with their controller implementation I've read. So Grin is the only game in town currently for being able to implement all the features and options of regen.
I
I broke the 12MM axle with regen and only one v7 regen torque arm. If you look up the torque required to break M12 axle, compared to M14 axle, the M14 is almost twice as strong.
I believe the axle broke because I only used a single v7 regen torque arm... and I was using quite high levels of regen to test It Lol.
I will try it again in the future, with two v7 regen torque arms and my G63. I feel fairly confident it would be OK with a V7 on each side.
Yes, the G63 .1000 motor that I ordered on ali express came with M14 by default. Bafang also makes the G900 hub motors with M14 axles, So it seems bafang is using M14 axles by default for the 750W+ motors now. But always check with the Ali express seller of course. If you see a bafang motor with the red L1121 motor cable connector, it probably has an M14 axle.
Im not sure how the engwe with regen works, But i imagine they have clamping dropouts on the bike? Or some kind of torque arms / torque plate that is very secure. It definitely needs something to hold the motor, beyond the standard hardware bafang provides.
I think Grin Tech , yeah, they realized the motor can just snap it's own axle, basically.
IT was necessary to use a special Loctite (548?? i forget) on the planet carrier to bind it to the axle , to avoid the "play" from the parallel key, when changing between acceleration and regen.
It was a lot of work - tinkering around, welding clutch etc. I will admit, it would be easier to just get the Grin tech all axle DD hub motor. But if you are a G62 enthusiast It is a fun project.
G62 Regen is no joke though You need V7 torque arms on each side!! and it cant be stressed enough.
I think the Nylon gears, when doing regen- there is probably something about going back and forth (accel and regen) with the nylon gears, as opposed to just 1 direction, that I imagine wears them out faster. I absolutely shredded some nylon gears hahah I would buy a bunch of spare nylon gears if doing regen.
(I dont know about using fully metal gears, with the welded clutch and regen, because I think if the gears broke it could lock up the wheel.)