I’ve only had my Creo for a little over a week. I did not have a road bike. I rode a 2001 M4 Stumpjumper with commuter tires (1 1/8”). I’ve only ridden the Creo about 90Km over the week, but I would turn to this bike over the Stumpy on each ride. I even rode with my family where they drove their bikes to the start of the ride. I decided to ride there. (It also saved putting on the rack, since we just dumped the two other bikes into the minivan.) It was easy to jump on the bike with little prep work.
I would not have done this with the Stumpy. The ride back has an 80m climb over the last 1km. Which is not a lot for many but I am not a strong rider (yet).
Would I ride the stumpy, again? Maybe. But I took the Creo on fire trail twice this week and it rode pretty close the stumpy on those trails. Most of my suspension was me off the saddle during the quicker parts so it felt similar to the 2000-era bike. For the stuff I ride, I’d probably turn to the Creo.
This sounds dumb, but I like looking at the Creo more. I like the sparkly grip tape and carbon looking frame. FWIW, I’m at an age where the small little smiles are getting important for me. I’m mid-40’s and having fun is my priority. This includes looking at the bike and saying, “That looks neat”.