Please Suggest Most Comfortable Saddle

[AnwerShakoor]

I am looking for most comfortable saddle for upright and slight lean position. I like wide saddles, any suggestions? I was looking at Cloud 9 Sunlite and Serfas RX-921L. Thanks!

 

[Sierratim]

I am looking for most comfortable saddle for upright and slight lean position. I like wide saddles, any suggestions? I was looking at Cloud 9 Sunlite and Serfas RX-921L. Thanks!

There's a lengthy thread on saddles here;

Saddle

I have a 2020 Vado 5.0 and thinking to change saddle. Does anyone have experience with Specialized S Works Power Arc ? Aside from the brand name what makes a saddle this expensive? Graphite? Is it much more comfortable to ride than less expensive good quality ones? here is a pic.

electricbikereview.com

Lots of current info and options.

 

[AnwerShakoor]

There's a lengthy thread on saddles here;

Saddle

I have a 2020 Vado 5.0 and thinking to change saddle. Does anyone have experience with Specialized S Works Power Arc ? Aside from the brand name what makes a saddle this expensive? Graphite? Is it much more comfortable to ride than less expensive good quality ones? here is a pic.

electricbikereview.com

Lots of current info and options.

Thanks!!!

 

[Stefan Mikes]

To make your decision easy: Selle Royal Premium Relaxed Journey. It is just a "sofa" saddle, very soft and large. You just "sit on a couch" while riding on that saddle. For upright riding position.

 

[AnwerShakoor]

To make your decision easy: Selle Royal Premium Relaxed Journey. It is just a "sofa" saddle, very soft and large. You just "sit on a couch" while riding on that saddle. For upright riding position.

Thanks for your suggestion ordering now!

 

[onlineaddy]

The “most comfortable” saddle is one that fits your anatomy and your riding style. It’s gonna be different from person to person.

 

[Bruce Arnold]

Cloud 9 works for me. I forget which version I have but they're all good.

 

[AnwerShakoor]

Cloud 9 works for me. I forget which version I have but they're all good.

Selle Royal Premium Relaxed Journey is not available anywhere therefore I bought Cloud 9 Sunlite.

 

[PennyWV]

Most comfortable saddle - a recumbent trike

 

[E-Wheels]

I am looking for most comfortable saddle for upright and slight lean position. I like wide saddles, any suggestions? I was looking at Cloud 9 Sunlite and Serfas RX-921L. Thanks!

I found this article very informative in the decision making process

Saddle Comfort for Cyclists: The Best Bicycle Touring Seats - CyclingAbout

Is your saddle comfortable? Unfortunately there is no 'go-to' bike seat, but luckily this resource will help you understand everything about saddle comfort.

www.cyclingabout.com

 

[Drbike]

There is no such thing as a comfortable bike seat. There ARE less uncomfortable seats butt that depends on the size, weight and shape of your a$$. Yes; I said this in a funny way, what works for one rider will not work for another.

 

[FlatSix911]

I am looking for most comfortable saddle for upright and slight lean position. I like wide saddles, any suggestions?
I was looking at Cloud 9 Sunlite and Serfas RX-921L. Thanks!

The most comfortable saddle for all-day rides... case closed.

 

[Stefan Mikes]

The most comfortable saddle for all-day rides... case closed.

View attachment 57681

The equestrian saddles are even more difficult selection, and expensive at that. Ask @Readytoride

 

[E-Wheels]

I have the Serfas RX-921L.

Honestly, it's just okay .. it is definitely NOT the most comfortable seat, but it is not bad.
If I do a long ride, my butt will still get hurt.
Also I found that it doesn't have much cushioning, I found the foam to be a bit on hard side.

I'd go for a wider cruiser type of saddle if you're looking for comfort.

For me the problem with the Serfas RX-921is the discomfort from the sharp stitching which is right on the edge of the centre cut out and runs the full length of the saddle

 

[tomjasz]

Selle Royal and Cloud 9. I have several Selle but always end up switching to the single cloud 9. But the happiest butt is on my Brooks.

 

[6zfshdb]

I agree with Drbike above. There is no such thing as a truly comfortable bicycle seat. If you want real comfort, you need a recumbent bike such as one of these trikes:

Recumbent Electric Bike Reviews | ElectricBikeReview.com

This style of electric bike positions the rider in a laid back position for comfort and aerodynamics. Cranks and pedals are usually mounted out front on an adjustable boom vs. directly below the seat tube and saddle. Instead of sitting on a saddle, most recumbent ebikes utilize a canvas chair...

electricbikereview.com

I'm presently looking at one for my wife.

There are 2 wheel recumbent bikes with comfortable back rest seats but they are awkward to mount especially for old folks like my wife and I.

 

[tomjasz]

recumbent bikes

Terrified myself after riding upright flat foot frames and being eye to eye with cages. Laying below traffic eye level was really spooky on busy streets. Never again. Great idea and I especially liked the ride comfort but was constantly paranoid after several close calls.

 

[GenXrider]

For me the problem with the Serfas RX-921is the discomfort from the sharp stitching which is right on the edge of the centre cut out and runs the full length of the saddle

I have the same issue sometimes with my new BV seat. I ride a lot of miles, always wearing biking shorts and sometimes am irritated by the stitching in an unpadded area in the buttocks area at the seam, and fortunately, I don't always notice it, including on a 3 1/2 hour yesterday, otherwise, I would have already ditched it. It's got some decent cushioning to it, feels very lightweight for its size, and has real metal springs rather than those elastomer springs I had on a previous seat.
https://www.amazon.com/BV-Bike-Saddle-Seat-Universal/dp/B074WH9TM3

 

[6zfshdb]

I have never ridden a recumbent bike so I can't speak from experience, but a lot of car seats are really uncomfortable and cause me back or neck pain.

My point is, even with recumbent bike, finding a comfortable seat might be just as challenging as bike.

Of course this all depends on the rider. From the limited experience I've had with recumbents, much of your weight is supported by your back which takes pressure off your butt. There are many configurations and like ordinary saddles, each rider has to find one that suits their particular needs.

 

[Johnmj1]

To make your decision easy: Selle Royal Premium Relaxed Journey. It is just a "sofa" saddle, very soft and large. You just "sit on a couch" while riding on that saddle. For upright riding position.

Couldn’t find it on the Selle Royal site.