Wow, the Storm has really blown up... Thanks for all of the great links and thoughts on this guys. I might have to jump on the band wagon and buy one to thoroughly review
What we know:
- Motor is a 380 watt gearless direct drive (though there have been some references to 350 watt and the motor in the video at the start of this thread looks much larger than the one in the photos of the Indiegogo campaign. A gearless motor offers lower torque than geared and is usually heavier.
- Battery is a Lithium-ion 36 volt ~10.55 ah and weighs 2.5 kg ~5.5 lbs (no branding for cell manufacturer as @Ann M. pointed out.
- Steel frame (reduces vibration, usually heavier than aluminum, may rust but shouldn't compromise frame integrity)
- Throttle mode only (range may suffer and finger/wrist may fatigue vs. pedal assist)
- Single speed (simple, requiring fewer tuneups and dropping less frequently, difficult to start from rest, not as efficient for climbing or reaching higher speeds)
What we think:
- 180 mm mechanical disc brakes with Zoom calipers based on photos (the Yahoo guy said hydraulic but maybe that's just the prototype? The pictures who mechanical)
- Lower quality Lithium-ion cells that may get ~500 full cycles vs. ~1,000
- No bottle cage or rear rack mounting points, may be able to fit fenders from Surface 604 like these but will have to customize
- Large plastic box for storing elicit substances while riding to the beach to chill with homies
I had an hour long phone conversation with someone about this bike today before thoroughly reviewing the post myself
on Indiegogo and wanted to share a few things we discussed.
- I love the awareness this campaign creates for ebikes in general but am a bit concerned about how it might erode perceived value in other models which cost more. Those higher costs go towards demoing, fitting and servicing which also helps the ebike movement.
- I question the delivery timeframe given past crowdfunding (see Copenhagen Wheel). The website says "Manufacturing begins March 15th, shipping begins May 1st and delivery is estimated at May" so hopefully everything goes smooth at the ports.
- I question the warranty and support... is there a warranty? it's nice to know that shipping will be less than $194 but if there's an issue, will that also cost $100+ to deal with if you have to send the bike back? Can you send the bike back?!
- Does it really weigh just 45 lbs... with the battery too? That's what they say but I find it difficult to believe given the steel frame and fat tires. For comparison, here are all of the fat bikes I've reviewed to date with weight listed on the 29th line a bit down. The lightest bike I've reviewed in this category is the $5,800 race-inspired 48 lb Felt Lebowske. This bike claims to be lighter than the lightest fat e-bike available in the US right now from what I can tell.
- Will 380 watts of gearless motor power be enough torque for sand/snow? Does it matter?!
- What's the quality of the battery cells? Replacing the Bosch Powerpack 400 is $900... Replacing an Easy Motion battery is $600+ varying by model... Replacing a polaris battery is $800 so what is the quality of the cells used on the Storm if it only costs ~$180?
- Is the savings worth the trade off in format and weight? I'm reminded of something my grandpa taught me... t's not a good deal if it's not something you actually need. The storm will take up a lot of space and likely perform at a mediocre level, it's a great price but is it something you need? Would that same $500 be better spent towards a city or mountain bike from a local dealer that would get more use, be portable and last longer?
- The marketing feels... a bit slick to me "The Storm eBike battery can also be charged by solar power for those of you feeling extra green!" I feel like I'm being talked down to... anything electric can be charged by solar :/ "The upgraded thumb throttle..." Upgraded?? Upgraded from what? Who are they talking to here?!
- Why is most of the post done with images instead of text, this makes it very difficult to search on page, reference via search engine or interpret for screen readers for disabled visitors.
If I was not running EBR I would probably not buy the Storm at this time because:
- I don't ride on sand or snow very often and I'm not sure this bike would handle it very well, especially if the sand is near a salty beach. that said... This thing is basically disposable at $500, which makes me kind of sad for the people who make it in Asia.
- Fat tires and tubes are more expensive to fix and replace than traditional, going to be a sad day when you get a flat and try to lug it to the local shop because...
- No quick release on wheels... big giant wheels that might not fit easily in my car for that ride at the beach or that fix at the shop
- One speed for a fat bike just doesn't seem like enough, even if it is the world's lightest fat ebike
- I'd feel like a tool riding it around because it just doesn't look that cool... but at least I wouldn't be p
- oor
Lots to think about here, given the single speed drivetrain and gearless motor there shouldn't be too many issues with the bike. The replacement batteries are so inexpensive, hopefully they stay available and cheap in a year or two. Even if it only gets a 10 mile range, that's still enough for fun and short errands and with a couple hours of charging it should be at or above 70% (they claim it would be 100% at this point). In short, I feel like they're stretching the truth on this bike and being overly promotional unnecessarily. The bike appears to be solid at that price as a crappy single speed fatty. Get it and forget it, let it rust and enjoy it in the sand or loan it to your friend. Who cares if it gets dinged at the bike rack or stolen eventually? You could buy three of these (with shipping) for the price of most regular ebikes. It makes me uneasy and reminds me of the bikes from
Big Cat which also used steel frames and weighted a lot more (the Phantom and Long Beach Cruiser weigh ~70 lbs!). I hope the bike isn't creating too many negative externalities or gray costs and I hope these thoughts help someone