Specialized, Trek or Orbea, which one?

[Akrotiri]

I

I would think that putting drop bars on a Vado SL4 using a Ritchie Beacon would be a good way to go. This is a gravel drop bar with a very shallow 80 degree drop and 36 degree flair, probably the least drop of any handlebar. At only $50 it would not be a terribly expensive experiment. Of course there is the cost of new brake lever/shifters cabling and hose. This would give you a chance to see how the bike functions with a drop bar that would be easier to adapt to because of its more moderate drop and reach. Also it would be wise to use an adjustable angle stem which would help find the most comfortable ride position.

https://us.ritcheylogic.com/us_en/comp-beacon-handlebar

View attachment 82259

I believe @Firnatine said the Vado SL is already converted to drop bar and wants to know if he should pull the trigger on it or look to purchase a standard flat bar Vado SL.

 

[Alaskan]

I

I believe @Firnatine said the Vado SL is already converted to drop bar and wants to know if he should pull the trigger on it or look to purchase a standard flat bar Vado SL.

We were having a discussion here. My comment may or may not be relevant to the OP.

I was suggesting a less radical modification in choice of handlebars in the event he chose to buy that bike rather than purchase a purpose made drop handlebar bike He was not looking to purchase a flat bar bike as you suggest. He began this thread inquiring about drop bar bikes and was only looking at this one because it has been converted to a drop bar.

I rarely, if ever, advise anyone to "pull the trigger" on a particular bike. Rather I try to share what information I am aware of that would help the inquiring person to make their own decision. This is what the OP asked for, information about a bike and its modifications that he had not been considering and wanted to know more about.

The OP is still an active part of the conversation. If he feels my observation is not relevant, he is free to either ignore it or ask that the conversation remain more narrowly focused. It not really your place to do so.

 

[Akrotiri]

We were having a discussion here. My comment may or may not be relevant to the OP.

I was suggesting a less radical modification in choice of handlebars in the event he chose to buy that bike rather than purchase a purpose made drop handlebar bike He was not looking to purchase a flat bar bike as you suggest. He began this thread inquiring about drop bar bikes and was only looking at this one because it has been converted to a drop bar.

I rarely, if ever, advise anyone to "pull the trigger" on a particular bike. Rather I try to share what information I am aware of that would help the inquiring person to make their own decision. This is what the OP asked for, information about a bike and its modifications that he had not been considering and wanted to know more about.

The OP is still an active part of the conversation. If he feels my observation is not relevant, he is free to either ignore it or ask that the conversation remain more narrowly focused. It not really your place to do so.

I’m sorry I didn’t mean to imply your comment wasn’t relevant. It always is ofcourse.

I re-read the thread and yes you’re correct he specifically was looking at it because it was a drop bar conversion. My mistake.

 

[Alaskan]

I’m sorry I didn’t mean to imply your comment wasn’t relevant. It always is ofcourse.

I re-read the thread and yes you’re correct he specifically was looking at it because it was a drop bar conversion. My mistake.

Thank you. We are good.

 

[Stefan Mikes]

I see how that was misleading, I said “Definitely not for a 4“ only because of the price. Fours are $1,000 less expensive than the fives. Meaning that the used Vado drop bar conversion on offer was overpriced for a 5 and very overpriced for a 4. Both good bikes. I’m looking at getting a Vado for my wife, if they ever come back in stock.

Thank you. I am sorry, I misread your post!

 

[ebikealex]

Having bought an Orbea Gain D31 in March 2020 and ridden it for a year and recently having replaced it with a Creo, I have to say that the Creo is far superior and the power delivery is much more linear and usable. The Orbea was a good bike, but the Mahle motor delivered the power very inconsistently and resulted in a jerky ride. The Creo by comparison feels really natural and the Diverge based frame is great. The first thing I did to both bikes is to change the tyres out for tubeless Continental Terra Speed (light) gravel tyres, which made a huge difference to the ride comfort and performance. The price difference between these two is about 3x, but there really is a world of difference.

 

[Ebiker33]

I'm new to the forum and looking for advice. I'm planning on buying an eBike in a month or two and have narrowed it down
to Specialized Turbo Creo Evo, Trek Domane HP+, or Orbea Gain M20i. I'm 72 and just started cycling last may. I ride a Santa Cruz Carbon
Stigmata and love it and plan to keep it. My reason for an eBike is I will be riding cross country this August with a group of firefighters for the 20th anniversary of 9/11. I will be the oldest in the group by 10 years with the least amount of cycling experience. The plan is to stay together and no one gets dropped. I don't want to be the guy that slows the group down so I hope the eBike will allow me to keep up. On the flats my Santa Cruz should be fine but there will be some major climbs to deal with that will be extremely challenging especially for a guy my age.

I really like the Turbo Creo Evo and leaning heavily in that direction. I like the fact its a gravel bike, doesn't look like an ebike, is under 30 lbs. and class 3. All the reviews I've read have been positive. The battery range is one of the best and the optional battery they claim would give 40 more miles. I see they just raised the price by $500 and stock is low.

The Domane HP+ has a more powerful motor that I would assume be better for the big climbs and it too is class 3. I don't like the weight at 39 lbs. which makes it 20 lbs. heavier then my Santa Cruz. Out of the 3 bikes, it is the most expensive.

For me the Orbea by far is the best looking of the 3 and does not look at all like an eBike. It is also the lightest at 26 lbs. It comes with Shimano Di2 and is more then a thousand dollars less then the others. I don't like the fact it is not class 3 with the assist only to 20mph. I also have concerns about the hub motor compared to the mid drive motor. The reviews I've read have been mixed. I've read the drag is noticeable once the assist quits.

I'm not looking for a free ride just some assist that will get me over the big bumps, has good range and comfortable to ride for 8 hours. I pretty much made up my mine but would love to hear others opinions to help assure me I'm making the right decision.

Thanks in advance.

Since you said you love your Santa Cruz analog, they make an Ebike, looks pretty good too.

 

[cj3209]

I'm new to the forum and looking for advice. I'm planning on buying an eBike in a month or two and have narrowed it down
to Specialized Turbo Creo Evo, Trek Domane HP+, or Orbea Gain M20i. I'm 72 and just started cycling last may. I ride a Santa Cruz Carbon
Stigmata and love it and plan to keep it. My reason for an eBike is I will be riding cross country this August with a group of firefighters for the 20th anniversary of 9/11. I will be the oldest in the group by 10 years with the least amount of cycling experience. The plan is to stay together and no one gets dropped. I don't want to be the guy that slows the group down so I hope the eBike will allow me to keep up. On the flats my Santa Cruz should be fine but there will be some major climbs to deal with that will be extremely challenging especially for a guy my age.

I really like the Turbo Creo Evo and leaning heavily in that direction. I like the fact its a gravel bike, doesn't look like an ebike, is under 30 lbs. and class 3. All the reviews I've read have been positive. The battery range is one of the best and the optional battery they claim would give 40 more miles. I see they just raised the price by $500 and stock is low.

The Domane HP+ has a more powerful motor that I would assume be better for the big climbs and it too is class 3. I don't like the weight at 39 lbs. which makes it 20 lbs. heavier then my Santa Cruz. Out of the 3 bikes, it is the most expensive.

For me the Orbea by far is the best looking of the 3 and does not look at all like an eBike. It is also the lightest at 26 lbs. It comes with Shimano Di2 and is more then a thousand dollars less then the others. I don't like the fact it is not class 3 with the assist only to 20mph. I also have concerns about the hub motor compared to the mid drive motor. The reviews I've read have been mixed. I've read the drag is noticeable once the assist quits.

I'm not looking for a free ride just some assist that will get me over the big bumps, has good range and comfortable to ride for 8 hours. I pretty much made up my mine but would love to hear others opinions to help assure me I'm making the right decision.

Thanks in advance.

I have the Pinarello Dyodo which is very similar to the Orbea Gain M20i. Assumming your ride is mainly tarmac and isn't over 60 miles per ride, I recommend the Orbea Gain for the following reasons:

1) I don't notice ANY drag on the hub motor and my Dyodo uses the exact same eMotion hub motor as the Orbea Gain M20i so riding without the hub motor assist is relatively easy on flats.
2) There is an extended batter option that will give you around 60+ hours but if you only use the hub motor during climbs, you can get more miles, even without the extended battery.
3) The eMotion hub motor really helps on hills at levels 2 and 3; since you only need the motor on hills, you can save battery life.
4) weighing at around 27-28 lbs really helps when cycling on flats and means you can ride the bike without a motor assist; the other ebikes (Creo and Domane) CANNOT be ridden without motor assist.

The main issue is that if you need the hub motor assist during the flats (maybe the group averages a speedy 22-24 MPH on the flats), you will run out of battery power at around 30-50 miles, depending on terrain.

But you will have to gauge your fitness level. I'm 52 and fairly fit for my age; I can keep up with most riders with my Aero Road Bike. I only use the eBike when I don't want to be exhausted after a 50+ miles ride or when exploring or need to get somewhere, very quickly.

Good luck!

CJ

 

[cj3209]

I have the Pinarello Dyodo which is very similar to the Orbea Gain M20i. Assumming your ride is mainly tarmac and isn't over 60 miles per ride, I recommend the Orbea Gain for the following reasons:

1) I don't notice ANY drag on the hub motor and my Dyodo uses the exact same eMotion hub motor as the Orbea Gain M20i so riding without the hub motor assist is relatively easy on flats.
2) There is an extended batter option that will give you around 60+ hours but if you only use the hub motor during climbs, you can get more miles, even without the extended battery.
3) The eMotion hub motor really helps on hills at levels 2 and 3; since you only need the motor on hills, you can save battery life.
4) weighing at around 27-28 lbs really helps when cycling on flats and means you can ride the bike without a motor assist; the other ebikes (Creo and Domane) CANNOT be ridden without motor assist.

The main issue is that if you need the hub motor assist during the flats (maybe the group averages a speedy 22-24 MPH on the flats), you will run out of battery power at around 30-50 miles, depending on terrain.

But you will have to gauge your fitness level. I'm 52 and fairly fit for my age; I can keep up with most riders with my Aero Road Bike. I only use the eBike when I don't want to be exhausted after a 50+ miles ride or when exploring or need to get somewhere, very quickly.

Good luck!

CJ

BTW, I also recommend the Canyon Grail-On as well; it is Class 3 and a BLAST to ride. It will easily give you 60+ miles on a charge (no extended battery available or needed). It's not cheap though.

 

[PedalUma]

I have the Pinarello Dyodo which is very similar to the Orbea Gain M20i. Assumming your ride is mainly tarmac and isn't over 60 miles per ride, I recommend the Orbea Gain for the following reasons:

1) I don't notice ANY drag on the hub motor and my Dyodo uses the exact same eMotion hub motor as the Orbea Gain M20i so riding without the hub motor assist is relatively easy on flats.
2) There is an extended batter option that will give you around 60+ hours but if you only use the hub motor during climbs, you can get more miles, even without the extended battery.
3) The eMotion hub motor really helps on hills at levels 2 and 3; since you only need the motor on hills, you can save battery life.
4) weighing at around 27-28 lbs really helps when cycling on flats and means you can ride the bike without a motor assist; the other ebikes (Creo and Domane) CANNOT be ridden without motor assist.

The main issue is that if you need the hub motor assist during the flats (maybe the group averages a speedy 22-24 MPH on the flats), you will run out of battery power at around 30-50 miles, depending on terrain.

But you will have to gauge your fitness level. I'm 52 and fairly fit for my age; I can keep up with most riders with my Aero Road Bike. I only use the eBike when I don't want to be exhausted after a 50+ miles ride or when exploring or need to get somewhere, very quickly.

Good luck!

CJ

The Orbea Gain is strange to ride in my opinion. Try putting it into the lowest gear and pedaling the slowest you can on the highest power level. That is how you will see the bike hit its top speed then cut out. Surge to its top speed and again cut out. The range on the Gain in the real world of hills and stops at intersections is very limited.
Their Range Extender is a $200 battery that they want $650 for.
The Creo is so much better to ride. Seamless. A real bike for people who ride bikes.
I just made the one in the photo. It has a lot of heavy things on it such as a big gel saddle and a .7 pound kickstand. It is 32.2 pounds with the gear. And will play with the Creo side-by-side. This is an old bike.

 

[cj3209]

The Orbea Gain is strange to ride in my opinion. Try putting it into the lowest gear and pedaling the slowest you can on the highest power level. That is how you will see the bike hit its top speed then cut out. Surge to its top speed and again cut out. The range on the Gain in the real world of hills and stops at intersections is very limited.
Their Range Extender is a $200 battery that they want $650 for.
The Creo is so much better to ride. Seamless. A real bike for people who ride bikes.
I just made the one in the photo. It has a lot of heavy things on it such as a big gel saddle and a .7 pound kickstand. It is 32.2 pounds with the gear. And will play with the Creo side-by-side. This is an old bike.

I have both a Class 1 and Class 3 eBike and, yes, they both cut out at 20 and 28 mph, respectively. Not sure why that's an issue as that is what they are designed to do. I usually only use the hub motor just before a hill or against a crosswind and it is very helpful.

 

[PedalUma]

I have both a Class 1 and Class 3 eBike and, yes, they both cut out at 20 and 28 mph, respectively. Not sure why that's an issue as that is what they are designed to do. I usually only use the hub motor just before a hill or against a crosswind and it is very helpful.

That is exactly what the Gain is for. I get it.

 

[StevenC56]

The Orbea Gain is strange to ride in my opinion. Try putting it into the lowest gear and pedaling the slowest you can on the highest power level. That is how you will see the bike hit its top speed then cut out. Surge to its top speed and again cut out. The range on the Gain in the real world of hills and stops at intersections is very limited.
Their Range Extender is a $200 battery that they want $650 for.
The Creo is so much better to ride. Seamless. A real bike for people who ride bikes.
I just made the one in the photo. It has a lot of heavy things on it such as a big gel saddle and a .7 pound kickstand. It is 32.2 pounds with the gear. And will play with the Creo side-by-side. This is an old bike.

I have never experienced this surge on my Gain. Why in the world would you even put it in the lowest gear and level 3 assist in real world riding? I wouldn't just because it doesn't make sense. Coming from a mechanical background, I know there's always a shortcoming or weak spot to any technology/product. It's amazing how people will so something out of the normal realm to purposely seek out these issues, and then home in on them over and over just to get upset about it or prove that they have a negative in their operating system.

 

[PedalUma]

You are correct. It is pushing limits like playing a guitar at the shortest part of the fretboard with the amplifier maxed.

 

[ebikealex]

BTW, I also recommend the Canyon Grail-On as well; it is Class 3 and a BLAST to ride. It will easily give you 60+ miles on a charge (no extended battery available or needed). It's not cheap though.

I have to say, I'm a huge fan of this bike and was torn between the two, but ultimately decided to go for the Creo because it's much lighter. I've never ridden a Grail:ON but they look like a blast.

 

[Rás Cnoic]

BTW, I also recommend the Canyon Grail-On as well; it is Class 3 and a BLAST to ride. It will easily give you 60+ miles on a charge (no extended battery available or needed). It's not cheap though.

Huh, I'm not sure the Creo can't be ridden unassisted?! I'm a similiar age 51 & I have a Vado SL 4 with same motor & battery and I ride it about 50% of the time without assist. Basically on the flats or downhill unless there is a strong headwind or I'm knackered. I was looking at the Ribble Al e which has the Mahle eMotion and is a lighter bike, but it's extremely hilly where I live with very steep gradients and the reports I read said the eMotion would struggle with low cadence on the 20%+ slopes. The Vado Sl is brilliant at climbing. If I was to go the drop bar route in the future & given how unashamedly expensive the Creo's(!) are, I now think I'd look at getting a Fazua equipped bike like the Cairn E Adventure gravel bike. I like the idea of being able to take the battery out and riding it like a normal bike. But I haven't ridden one so I can't compare the Fazua motor to the Speccy one.

 

[Rás Cnoic]

It can. Just set it to power level 0 with the Road Remotes.

Yep, but I was replying to a poster who said that unlike riding an Orbea E Motion bike you couldn't ride a Creo without assistance.

 

[cj3209]

Yep, but I was replying to a poster who said that unlike riding an Orbea E Motion bike you couldn't ride a Creo without assistance.

I meant that it's pretty hard to ride a heavy bike without the motor assist, unless you are only on flats. The Creo is pretty heavy right? Over 40 lbs?

 

[Stefan Mikes]

I meant that it's pretty hard to ride a heavy bike without the motor assist, unless you are only on flats. The Creo is pretty heavy right? Over 40 lbs?

Aluminum Creo weighs 33 lbs with pedals - that come with bike
Carbon one weighs 29lbs.

 

[cj3209]

vdev said:
Aluminum Creo weighs 33 lbs with pedals - that come with bike
Carbon one weighs 29lbs.

That's not too bad. My eMotion road bike is 27 lbs and my eGravel bike is 37lbs.