I'm interested to hear more about your experience with the Shadow. The stock shifters and derailleur are fine, but if there's a significant improvement at a reasonable price...Hi John, good news for you: last week in repairing my crashed bike I installed a 56T narrow-wide chainring and it clears the chainstay just fine. Also, a 10S Shadow + clutch derailleur was put on with astonishingly good results! NO MORE CHAIN DROPS, whooooopeee! And the already great shifting of the stock 9S is further improved. I will make a thread about it someday after more evaluation of the new drivetrain.
If you are not dropping chain the 9S stock setup is fine.I'm interested to hear more about your experience with the Shadow. The stock shifters and derailleur are fine, but if there's a significant improvement at a reasonable price...
Hi John, good news for you: last week in repairing my crashed bike I installed a 56T narrow-wide chainring and it clears the chainstay just fine. Also, a 10S Shadow + clutch derailleur was put on with astonishingly good results! NO MORE CHAIN DROPS, whooooopeee! And the already great shifting of the stock 9S is further improved. I will make a thread about it someday after more evaluation of the new drivetrain.
Is there a way to easy verify the battery capacity? Was suppose to get the 19.2ah battery but documentation says it's 17.4. Guessing it just wasn't updated but would like to double check.
I'm guessing that the documentation hasn't been updated yet. They sold out of the 17.4s a while back - I got one of the last ones - so the probability that you got the wrong battery approaches zero.Is there a way to easy verify the battery capacity? Was suppose to get the 19.2ah battery but documentation says it's 17.4. Guessing it just wasn't updated but would like to double check.
There should be a sticker on the battery itself telling you the capacity.
I'm guessing that the documentation hasn't been updated yet. They sold out of the 17.4s a while back - I got one of the last ones - so the probability that you got the wrong battery approaches zero.
But hey, email them for confirmation. They've always replied within 24 hrs with answers to my questions.
Slow, can you post a pic of your chain guide installed? Thanks.The FAQ on the Juiced Websites list a few things you can do to avoid chain drops. I haven't seen that mentioned here in the forum, so I thought I post the link.
https://juicedbikes.happyfox.com/kb...ring-when-going-over-bumps-or-shifting-gears/
I installed the exact chain catcher that is listed (K-Edge Cross Single) there after I had two chain drops during my first ten rides or so. So far, so good - no more drops. Time will tell if it is going to hold up.
The chain catcher is a bit pricy for what it is, but it fits perfectly and I was able to get a returned but new one for $20 on eBay.
Here are some pictures of the installed K-edge chain catcher. I angled it slightly to get closer to the chain.
View attachment 20747View attachment 20748
Hi John, good news for you: last week in repairing my crashed bike I installed a 56T narrow-wide chainring and it clears the chainstay just fine. Also, a 10S Shadow + clutch derailleur was put on with astonishingly good results! NO MORE CHAIN DROPS, whooooopeee! And the already great shifting of the stock 9S is further improved. I will make a thread about it someday after more evaluation of the new drivetrain after I heal up and can really pedal the bike.
Reid, if you don't mind me asking, what do you think was the total cost of your conversion to the 10S shadow system? I am trying to decide if I will just want to try a chain guide or if I should just jump to your setup. Obviously cost is a big part of the decision. For those who have just gone with a chain guide, are you satisfied with the lack of chain drops and overall function? For those who have done nothing, how often are you experiencing chain drops? Thanks.If you are not dropping chain the 9S stock setup is fine.
In not very brief, what I have recently gleaned from the 'net: 9S is many years ago stuff. There must be tons of it remaining unwanted in the supply lanes. 10S came along quite a few years back now, and then shortly thereafter, 11S became the new keep-up-with-the-Jones', gotta-have-it bike bling
We don't need so many gears, of course, but the clutch-type tech of Shimano (they bundle it with their "Shadow" lower protruding derailleur tech) Plus and the similar clutch, Sram makes, only came out for 10S and 11S (and we presume for 12S to come). 9S is not supported by the new anti-chain-drop tech, although you can get a narrow-wide chainring (more in a bit) and use that for a possible total cure for your chain drop issues.
The Shimano Shadow derailleurs are for mountain bikes. The SPRING on that Shadow tension arm is a great deal stronger than our stock CCS 9S tension arms, a big plus toward reduction of chainring chain drop incidents. The CLUTCH of of the Shadow Plus adds yet additional control to the chain, reducing jouncing of the upper length of the chain. When a chain jounces left or right and there is no effective guide, the chain runs off the upper half of the chainwheel.
I am not "pontificating," I hope. I mean only to describe what I have learned as seen from my own perspective.
Months ago I shortened the stock chain and experienced for 200 or so miles NO chain drops! I thought I had the issue licked. But the cocked-back tension spring must have lost some tension...the spring weakened over a span of time, I guess. After a week or so the pattern of chain drops returned as bad as ever.
Besides a much stronger tension arm spring (which seems to be the single most valuable step to reduce chain drops) and the Shadow Plus Shimano derailleurs, there is also the cure of the narrow-wide tooth chainring.
I cannot advise which one is most curative of chain drops because I adopted the three expedients at the same time: a 56T narrow-wide chainring, a derailleur with a MUCH stronger tension arm spring, PLUS it has that one-way friction clutch Shimano pairs with its low-protrusion Shadow MTB derailleur lineup that they call Plus.
The Shadow Plus derailleur upgrade gave me 10 gears and absolutely requires changing to a 10S cassette and a 10S trigger shifter and a 10S chain.
Were I on a budget I would have gotten only the narrow-wide chainring to see if that curative step is sufficient by itself. It will work with 9S chain.
hth.
PS: Early on, before I gave up and bought the gear above, I tried but failed to find any successful chain guide for our stock 52T chainwheels. There may be one. And my bike's factory supplied chainring bash guard did not prevent chain drops on its side at all; I could not see bending it, that would look nasty, and reversing it would not have brought it any closer to the chainring. Besides that, half the time the chain dropped from the left side of the chainring, where there is no room for a guide ring.
About $65 for the 10s Shadow Plus long cage derailleur and $30 for the 10s shifter and $27 for the extended range 10s cassette. Add also $37 for a 56T narrow-wide chainring that may be considered optional.Reid, if you don't mind me asking, what do you think was the total cost of your conversion to the 10S shadow system?