eMTB Options For 2024

I'm betting it's a typo in the specs. The E+2Pro is 35mm as are the rest of the trance-E's.
Stance are "25mm ebike optimized tubeless ready". 29 though. More on this...

Well, you guys aren't gonna believe this...
Shop called, said it's ready. Wife drove down, we got lunch, went to the shop, they're dinking around, 'got pedals?'... we're charging it. Oh, and "it's a used bike, a customer return, so no warranty. Not sure if we can put it on your synchrony account". No problem. But wait, 'no warranty'? On a ebike? "It was already registered, and Giant doesn't transfer warranty." Oh boy, I blew my stack. "We'll warranty it for 30 days". Uh, no, not on a ebike. A regular bike I wouldn't care, but not an ebike.

For gods sakes. They put it in the line up with the new bikes, with a price tag sticker just like the new bikes. Wife doesn't have time to stand there and haggle over it. Never even got to try it. "Previous owner had a problem with the battery, decided on a different bike." Really?

Refunded deposit. I was seeing red. Lots of explanation, lots of excuses and apologies. They'll be lucky if I ever set foot in there again. This is NOT how you treat customers, let alone a repeat customer.

Went shopping on Giant.com - dealer 50 miles away has on 2021 Stance E+1 in M. MSRP $4550. "I'll take it." :rolleyes:

'Desert Sage' 29-r. Turns out the 21 model has the 625w pack with sport motor - I'm good with all that. RockShox Recon - ok, SRAM Eagle 12, that's good, dropper post -check, size M, check.
We are slated to pick it up Saturday. 😒

View attachment 84172
Dayum! That sucked, but kudos for standing your ground.
 
Ouch! Just out of interest, if they had explained it was second hand / limited warranty would you have bought it? The stance will be more than enough bike, but there were lots of components on that trance that were transferable to yours in a worst case scenario.
 
Today I had planned to hire a levo sl and do some alpine riding, but we went bushwalking early in the day, had a lazy lunch, then I discovered the shop closed at 4 pm - nah, it was too nice a day to rush.

I'm REALY glad I took the full e pro - just 10 km, but 300 m of ascending and then descending. All TIGHT, technical and lots of uphill rocky climbs. I don't know how sprogette managed it on her mebike, but I was totally exhausted and VERY happy to have full power.

I was too busy in the technical sections to take photos, but here's a teaser
EE8341C6-BC35-4F06-8C26-EA1EDA7C0EC4.jpeg
67CF7EE3-CCDB-442D-B070-C9CA61117419.jpeg1C875DCE-0D6F-4678-9872-B3D90209F79B.jpeg
 
Damn what a let down! But you did the right thing, no warranty on a return that had battery issues! No thanks!
But while you were there the Norco Sight didn't catch your eye?;)
Sure, they're all nice looking bikes. Eight grand isn't in our reality.
Ouch! Just out of interest, if they had explained it was second hand / limited warranty would you have bought it? The stance will be more than enough bike, but there were lots of components on that trance that were transferable to yours in a worst case scenario.

I don't think so. My motive wasn't to potentially get upgrades for mine - it's good as-built. And really, for 10% more, the newest version of Stance for her is a better deal, and full factory warranty. And yes, that model will be more than adequate for her. It might see 10 to 20% off-road use. I already have a set of Schwalbe Hurricane tires coming for it.
I was most unhappy with the misrepresentation of what it was. There was no effort to disclose the status till they prepared to finalize the sale. Like a truth-bomb. Again, for a pedal-bike I would have been fine with it. But chasing gremlins on a problem ebike out of warranty isn't my idea of fun. I really dislike being jerked around, intentional or not.
 
What I find interesting is that bike being resold. Presumably whatever the original issue was is covered by the original warranty. I'm surprised giant is allowing the resale of effectively a factory second - unless it's the dealer having traded the bike in and selling a second hand bike.

Reflecting back on when my motor was replaced, the display / app etc registered the bike as having zero km , yet there was close to 5000 km on the battery / running gear. I can't imagine the lbs selling my worn out beast!
 
Sure, they're all nice looking bikes. Eight grand isn't in our reality.


I don't think so. My motive wasn't to potentially get upgrades for mine - it's good as-built. And really, for 10% more, the newest version of Stance for her is a better deal, and full factory warranty. And yes, that model will be more than adequate for her. It might see 10 to 20% off-road use. I already have a set of Schwalbe Hurricane tires coming for it.
I was most unhappy with the misrepresentation of what it was. There was no effort to disclose the status till they prepared to finalize the sale. Like a truth-bomb. Again, for a pedal-bike I would have been fine with it. But chasing gremlins on a problem ebike out of warranty isn't my idea of fun. I really dislike being jerked around, intentional or not.
Had my fill of those clowns that jerk people around like they know nothing, what soured me on auto dealers was going in the showroom and knowing more about the cars than the "salespeople"( so glad my next purchase is direct- you wouldn't believe some of the "hokey deals") I have been subject to( " you learn better than you die"{ adapted from the "Sayings of Plata'}' Good for you for "sticking to your guns".
Actually found a good deal on a Giant Bike yesterday at a young ladies' bike shop, She was very above board, didn't buy the bike,did buy an overpriced cup of good coffee and danish though.
 
Latest News

Jacek has got my Trance E+ as a long term loan. I need him, his son Sebastian and younger brother Piotr all enjoy riding an FS e-MTB. Jacek is to maintain the e-bike at his cost.

Now, Jacek was able to make the "Monster" unusable very early ;) Everybody's complaining on the Giant RideControl EVO display as water-prone, and Jacek was able to prove that. He washed the bike and after Monster dried up, it turned out the display must have got some water inside, making the motor not willing to cooperate.

Now, Jacek is in his mechanical/electrical paradise ;) He has already uninstalled the EVO, had dried it up in a bag of rice, now disassembling to assess the state of the motherboard. Meanwhile, he would come to my temporary flat and collect the original RideControl One remote, and install it on the bike.

Good luck, brother! :)
 
What I find interesting is that bike being resold. Presumably whatever the original issue was is covered by the original warranty. I'm surprised giant is allowing the resale of effectively a factory second - unless it's the dealer having traded the bike in and selling a second hand bike.

Reflecting back on when my motor was replaced, the display / app etc registered the bike as having zero km , yet there was close to 5000 km on the battery / running gear. I can't imagine the lbs selling my worn out beast!

The way they explained it, the previous owner had the bike for several months but didn't ride it. I don't know what total miles were on it, but it looked like a new bike. I did find it odd that there was some dirt/dust on the cables below the motor where they exit and reenter the chainstay, and a couple of minor scratches on one side of the battery pack. Well, this would explain that. They said the bike wouldn't power up, but whatever that issue was they had 'fixed' or remedied under warranty, but the customer decided they wanted a 'hybrid bike', I assume to mean a different bike, so they accepted it back as a trade-in and sold him a new bike.

All would have been fine if they had put it in a line up of used bikes with a tag on it as 'previously sold' or 'used bike' or even 'demonstrator' with a note that they would warranty the bike for 30 days but that the original factory warranty was not transferable. A simple sticker on a hang-tag would have sufficed, that way any customer looking at it would have everything disclosed.

In my mind, the big detractor on this whole thing is that Giant does not transfer the warranty to subsequent owners when the time from original sale is still within the warranty period. I think that is completely wrong. Car warranties surely transfer, don't they? The car is warranted by the manufacturer for defects regardless of who the owner is nor how many times it has been passed on to another owner.

Frankly I don't think it was intentional fraud, I just think they're too busy and don't pay attention enough, have too many uninformed employees with too much to do, and it just got stickered with a price and put on the floor with the other eMTB's. They put an information sticker with model and stock number, msrp and selling price on every right-hand fork leg of every bike. Which is nice when you're shopping and looking, but that sticker could have easily had text that said resale or used. I admonished them severely for this, and it really soured the whole buying experience, regardless of whether it was intentional or not.

And yeah, I said to the manager, for an ebike, if six months down the road the motor craps out it could cost me a couple of grand to fix it. Giant warranties their bikes for one year, frame for life. For all we know a 2020 model had already ran out the clock. But had all that been explained upfront things may have been quite different. By now I was livid, completely soured on the deal. So I walked away. It's probably still a decent deal, if it works well, has no issues.

A perfect example of how you turn a high-value repeat customer into a non-customer for life.

Now, the new dealer claims they are the highest volume dealer for Giant MTB's in the country, or the state, I forget what they mentioned. They said Giant makes sure they get bikes to sell. They have a few eMTB's to sell, so I'm curious to see what kind of shop they have - it's up on the other side of Los Angeles, a good drive for Saturday morning. They took a $100 deposit, said they would assemble the bike out of the crate and charge it, have it ready to go on Saturday when we get there.

No shops are discounting off msrp, nor including any sales tax, and charge to replace or exchange parts like saddles bars, pedals or tires. Oh well. There's more demand for bikes than there are dealers and bikes. It's been this way since the pandemic hit, just over a year ago.

I'm pretty excited even just to find a new current-year bike available for sale, within a reasonable driving distance, that should suit our needs perfectly, for not much more than the steal-deal I thought I was getting. It's funny, once you make the buying decision you feel obligated to pursue that 'till you actually buy one. I felt like I was letting the wife down.

Which reveals a car-buying statistic...
My BIL sold Fords for fourteen years. He always said that once a customer sits down and negotiates a deal to buy a new car, if for any reason that deal doesn't go thru, or they can't finalize negotiations, they buy elsewhere within 7 days. And that's why a good sales person knows that if you're ready to sit down and buy, you're serious - you're going to buy from SOMEBODY. And you're NOT coming back! They called them 'be-backs'. When a prospect doesn't sit down to buy, and wants to flake on the sales guy, they say they'll 'Be Back' later. Another 'be-back'. LOL The chance of a be-back actually coming back is one or two percent, and why they try to put you on a car while they have you in the store - cuz you're not coming back! 😁
 
Last edited:
I think giant has 2 years warranty on electrics , but it's not transferable to new owners, and also replacement electrics don't have their own 2 year warranty period.

They used to claim the non transferable warranty was because second buyers had no way to be certain the original owner hadn't breached warranty by , eg, derestricting the bike. Yet other brands seem capable of transferring warranty ( eg specialized) .

I'd hate to try and sell a giant second hand
 
But chasing gremlins on a problem ebike out of warranty isn't my idea of fun. I really dislike being jerked around, intentional or not.

Yea, Knowledge is power !

I wish everyone would know the possible pitfalls of buying a used E bike w/o the warranty or dealers nearby. At least 6months wrrty. should be okay...but the one buying does not know : was the battery ever dropped , was the battery opened and the seller replaced the cells and so many other things... they can also use matching spray paint to cover hidden past drops/etc..
I don't know , I was thinking about making a thread about banning for sale used ebikes w/o warranty, esp. ads from new members... too many people/newbies will get swindled . I've been through one such experience as the newbie ebiker long time ago back in 2015. The used ebike ended up costing 4x more...

Ty for this thread with great emtb knowledge !
 
I don't know , I was thinking about making a thread about banning for sale used ebikes w/o warranty, esp. ads from new members... too many people/newbies will get swindled . I've been through one such experience as the newbie ebiker long time ago back in 2015. The used ebike ended up costing 4x more...

Think that through - if you ban adverts for used ebikes how does anyone sell a legitimate used bike? What about the enviromental implications? Or the people who can't afford a new bike but have the brains to spot a dud?

I normally upgrade my mtb every 3 years, my bike is out of warranty and well used, but the asking price would reflect that AND I'd be open with any potential buyer about the bikes limitations. No different to selling a used motorbike, and in over 35 years I've never had an unhappy purchaser .

Because of covid supply ussues, I suspect that I'll be keeping it another couple of years now - even if I buy something new I'd want a back up given the difficulties people are experiencing with warranty / parts supply. I almost feel guilty having spare bikes whilst people are desperate
 
😁
Think that through - if you ban adverts for used ebikes how does anyone sell a legitimate used bike? What about the enviromental implications? Or the people who can't afford a new bike but have the brains to spot a dud?

I normally upgrade my mtb every 3 years, my bike is out of warranty and well used, but the asking price would reflect that AND I'd be open with any potential buyer about the bikes limitations. No different to selling a used motorbike, and in over 35 years I've never had an unhappy purchaser .

Because of covid supply ussues, I suspect that I'll be keeping it another couple of years now - even if I buy something new I'd want a back up given the difficulties people are experiencing with warranty / parts supply. I almost feel guilty having spare bikes whilst people are desperate

A thirty percent discount had been applied to their selling price for the used TranceE. That's probably reasonable, but if it were a private party sale I would be expecting more like 40% off. I said that to the manager, to which he replied, "We're confident with the selling price on that bike.". Oh, are ya now. LOL
They wanted me out of there - I was making the other customers nervous. 😜 There was no way the wife was gonna jump into the middle of all that, thank goodness for that.
 
if you ban adverts for used ebikes how does anyone sell a legitimate used bike?
I know that of course, it is a forum thread i intended to make , but obviously it will be very divisive.

It would be helpful to hear from the people who actually bought used ebikes without warranty how has their experience been. Mine was not good, so in retrospect i wish that i was not allowed to buy it😉.

If it were sold from a well known member on Ebr then that should def. be allowed. I would have trust in that more then in a reg. Bike store.
 
😁


A thirty percent discount had been applied to their selling price for the used TranceE. That's probably reasonable, but if it were a private party sale I would be expecting more like 40% off. I said that to the manager, to which he replied, "We're confident with the selling price on that bike.". Oh, are ya now. LOL
They wanted me out of there - I was making the other customers nervous. 😜 There was no way the wife was gonna jump into the middle of all that, thank goodness for that.
Been there done that! LOL..
 
😁


A thirty percent discount had been applied to their selling price for the used TranceE. That's probably reasonable, but if it were a private party sale I would be expecting more like 40% off. I said that to the manager, to which he replied, "We're confident with the selling price on that bike.". Oh, are ya now. LOL
They wanted me out of there - I was making the other customers nervous. 😜 There was no way the wife was gonna jump into the middle of all that, thank goodness for that.
Wouldn't you like to be a fly on the wall for the next staff meeting?
 
Back