I'm new here and much appreciate this thread, thank you Toman. Right now I'm most interested in these two bikes (I think the also mentioned Santa Cruz Skitch takes a boost rear wheel, a nonstarter for me) for my first ebike.
The Creo 2 checks all the boxes, including mild front suspension, remote emotor controls on bars, standard through axle sizes, and wide tire capability, but I'd love to test ride one so I'll start looking for a Specialized demo ride day either in nearby Boone, NC, USA or in Charlotte, which is just over two hours away.
I test rode a Cervelo once, and the fit, ride, and feel was fantastic. So while cost and tires (max width 43.5mm) of the cervelo Rouvida are negatives, the ride feel might be fantastic enough to win me over, for some road and much gravel fun. Dont know how often I'd switch it to road-mode, especially since that action might require LBS action. Demos for Cervelo are likely limited but I'll keep an eye out.
Perspective such as that from PetroK on the Creo 2 is superhelpful.
-Tom