I got my replacement in August after the rubber buttons broke and I got tired of using my fingernail to push the buttons.
The Mint box was cheaper and I got it on sale for twelve bucks,..
The OtterBox isn't waterproof so I checked if my phone was,..
So apparently my phone isn't submersible, but rain should be fine.
I didn't like the teal color, and it tasted the same as the black case, but I realized that I only needed the rubber part and I could reuse the old black plastic part that already has the anti-slip velcro hook tape attached to it.
It not only prevents my phone from slipping out of my pocket, it also picks up the lint while it's in there.