How do you like your mid-drive City Commuter?
- Thread starter Va. Bch. Electric Bike Center
- Start date
Yes, I do as well. I'm a little disappointed in the sensor communication delay, particularly after a pause in pedaling. Reaction is even slower than the hub/cadence system...odd. Are you experiencing anything like this?
Mikey-
Active Member
You're talking about pedaling from a stop?
no, It seems ok in that situation...but after any pause in pedaling and then restart of pedaling, it takes a long time for any assistance to come back on.
TForan
Well-Known Member
I have a bike with torque and shift sensing and that's nothing I've experienced.
Mikey-
Active Member
We've customized City Commuters to similar spec, but I haven't had my hands on the Black Edition yet.
Ravi Kempaiah
Well-Known Member
- Region
- Canada
- City
- Halifax
I guess Pedego brought this onboard just to appease the mid-drive frenzy. But the Dapu drive is not very refined even though it has lots of power.
It is possible to tune the shift sensing delay but not all torque sensors are created equal. So, the inherent delay would still remain. I still can't believe Pedego spec'd a $15 shifter on this bike.
In terms of smoothness and sensitivity, Brose stand out, Yamaha comes close, followed by Bosch, Shimano etc.
Drives like Bafang MAX, Dapu, TranzX are good and can definitely use some improvement.
I'm brand new to ebikes. Never on an ebike before and little rusty riding any bike. A few days ago I visited a Pedego store and took both a 28" rear hub City and the 26" mid-drive. I was surprised that I liked the mid-drive better. The rear hub felt more powerful, like the bike was being pushed from the rear, a little bit faster than I cared for. The mid-drive felt more natural and more easy to control. Part of it may be that I am 5'4" short and felt more comfortable on the smaller frame. Still looking for my first ebike and have not decided on which drive as of yet.
That's my plan. The store I visited didn't have a 26" city commuter to try. Thanks for your input. How do you like your interceptor and how does your husband like his city commuter?Why not try a 26" inch hub drive Pedego, too whether an interceptor or a city commuter? I'm 5'5" and have a 26" interceptor. My husband is 5'9" and has a 26" city commuter. The city commuter also has adjustable handlebars, that make it easier to fit to the rider.
Stromer2work
Active Member
Rear hub adding too much power? Turn the settings down. You are aware the mid-drive power transfers thru the bike drivetrain as compared to a hub motor, correct? Most ebike drivetrains are just bicycle drivetrains, so on the mid-drive setup, you may experience increased wear and maintenance on your chain, rings, etc. This is due to the extra power being transferred thru components that were designed to transfer less. Personally, I don't care for the feeling and sound the bicycle drivetrain makes while shifting under the additional torque/force/stress of the 500+ watt motor, with my 600 watt legs. It's very clunky and loud.
TForan
Well-Known Member
My mid drive shifts silently. And to me feels much more natural than a hub drive. At least the ones I have tried.
ebikemom
Well-Known Member
We love them! We have the "old" controller, which may give a different riding experience than the "new" controller that breaks up the PAS differently, though I heard from Pedego that they are working to fix this experience difference issue. Don't know if it is resolved yet.
From reading here, I've learned that the mid-drive "naturalness" doesn't seem to be a benefit for folks doing suburban/urban/bike trail type riding, but IS a benefit for those doing mountain bike type riding. On a hub drive bike you feel the PAS kick in. Is that a problem, or does it feel good? (for me, the latter! My daughter said, when she experienced it, "It's like feeling mommy pedal like you did when we were little (we had bike trailers that converted our bikes to tandems so kids could pedal, too). I like that boost feeling when it kicks in. My understanding is that mid-drives don't have that feeling, even as they assist, so that is what folks mean when they say it is more "natural." Hub drives also don't put any strain/wear on the ordinary components of the bike (the chain and gears), which mid-drives do.
See what you like. There's not a correct answer except the one that you come to for yourself. Have fun!
TForan
Well-Known Member
We love them! We have the "old" controller, which may give a different riding experience than the "new" controller that breaks up the PAS differently, though I heard from Pedego that they are working to fix this experience difference issue. Don't know if it is resolved yet.
From reading here, I've learned that the mid-drive "naturalness" doesn't seem to be a benefit for folks doing suburban/urban/bike trail type riding, but IS a benefit for those doing mountain bike type riding. On a hub drive bike you feel the PAS kick in. Is that a problem, or does it feel good? (for me, the latter! My daughter said, when she experienced it, "It's like feeling mommy pedal like you did when we were little (we had bike trailers that converted our bikes to tandems so kids could pedal, too). I like that boost feeling when it kicks in. My understanding is that mid-drives don't have that feeling, even as they assist, so that is what folks mean when they say it is more "natural." Hub drives also don't put any strain/wear on the ordinary components of the bike (the chain and gears), which mid-drives do.
See what you like. There's not a correct answer except the one that you come to for yourself. Have fun!
My mid drive has power from the first half revolution and continues from there. I could really feel the unsprung weight of a hub drive and I can't imagine bouncing over curbs with it. I realize that is something that not everyone does but I sure do !
Last edited:
TForan
Well-Known Member
Bouncing over curbs? Nope, not something the ordinary commuter/city rider needs in their repertoire, in general!
Well, maybe not need but.......
Thanks. I I'm glad to hear that you enjoy your Pedegos. While I have you on the phone, do you have occasion to transport your Pedegos, and if so, how?We love them! We have the "old" controller, which may give a different riding experience than the "new" controller that breaks up the PAS differently, though I heard from Pedego that they are working to fix this experience difference issue. Don't know if it is resolved yet.
From reading here, I've learned that the mid-drive "naturalness" doesn't seem to be a benefit for folks doing suburban/urban/bike trail type riding, but IS a benefit for those doing mountain bike type riding. On a hub drive bike you feel the PAS kick in. Is that a problem, or does it feel good? (for me, the latter! My daughter said, when she experienced it, "It's like feeling mommy pedal like you did when we were little (we had bike trailers that converted our bikes to tandems so kids could pedal, too). I like that boost feeling when it kicks in. My understanding is that mid-drives don't have that feeling, even as they assist, so that is what folks mean when they say it is more "natural." Hub drives also don't put any strain/wear on the ordinary components of the bike (the chain and gears), which mid-drives do.
See what you like. There's not a correct answer except the one that you come to for yourself. Have fun!
Similar threads
