Bicycle helmet safety testing, interesting technical study

EMGX

Well-Known Member

"Below is a summary of the key findings:

  • The least protective helmet had a 2.62 times higher overall head injury risk than the most protective helmet. There was a lesser spread of linear risk (1.76 times) compared to rotational risk (4.21 times).
  • The pXR and pZR impact locations produced highest linear and rotational risks, respectively.
  • The nine helmets offering the best overall injury protection were all equipped with the anti-rotation technology MIPS, which in direct helmet comparisons between models with MIPS and no-MIPS versions, was shown to be effective in reducing rotational kinematics and risk under the impact conditions tested. However, not all helmets equipped with MIPS were the most protective.
  • Mass and price in isolation did not demonstrate a significant effect on exposure-weighted linear, rotational and overall risk, P(injury@helmet). However, the OLS model predicting non-exposure-weighted overall risk, P(injury@location), using price, mass, presence of MIPS and impact location showed that both price and mass had a small influence on the non-exposure-weighted overall risk, with increased mass and price shown to relate to increased non-exposure-weighted overall risk."
 
A few years ago there was an article in one of the motorcycling magazines about helmet effectiveness. Their conclusion, after serious testing, was that DOT tested helmets were at least as safe as the more expensive SNELL certified ones (do I have that name right?--it's been a long time). The amount of work they put into the testing was impressive--it wasn't just opinions of a few "experts." I don't know whether their investigations would apply to bike helmets. Maybe not at all.
 
1728599267705.png

They like the Specialized helmets as does Virginia Tech
 
The comparison that carries more weight for me is injury from a helmet versus injury with no helmet. I wiped out on a single track trail and hit the side of my head on rocky ground wearing my Fox Flux helmet. I don't want to think what would of happened without a helmet in the same situation (concussion at best to brain injury at worse). Upgraded to Bell Sixer MIPS last year.
 
View attachment 183891
They like the Specialized helmets as does Virginia Tech
Interestingly, Align and especially Echelon (that I use) are not high on the Virginia Tech list. Which is surprising as I can bet I could see the Align very high in that list just several months ago!
 
Stefan I see what you meant. The WayBackMachine says my Tactic and Align helmets were rated 1st and 9th two years ago. Now they are 4th and 17th.
 
Back