No, YOU let me know when it loosens when pedaling forward ... I won't hold my breath either, awaiting your success. There are BEARINGS in the pedal. When you were holding spindle with the wrench, you simulated failed bearings, I wrote this earlier.Ok, take a loose pedal, hold it against the crank arm, and simulate pedalling forward...let me know when it tightens. I will not hold my breath awaiting your sucess.