I thought I would revive this old thread to relate a short but interesting conversation I had today.
I was riding Pennsylvania's Lehigh Gorge Trail this morning and came up to a middle aged, spandex clad rider on a conventional MTB. He was stopped at a trail turnout, admiring the view. I pulled up next to him and tried to start a casual conversation. From the look he gave me, it was obvious he didn't care for e-bikes, so I asked him why. He thought for a moment and said "They dilute the perception I have of my own abilities." I had to think about that one until he added, "When someone twice my age can ride twice as far, twice as fast and stay on the trail twice as long, it lessens the way I feel about my own abilities". I tried to explain he was comparing apples to oranges when talking about conventional vs e-bikes, but he wasn't interested in continuing the conversation and just rode away.
Most of the conventional bike riders I encounter on the trail are friendly. Most are indifferent about e-bikes and others are curious. Some ask questions which I try my best to answer. Very few say it's cheating or display any animosity. That's why this particular encounter was so strange to me.
In thinking about it, I suppose the guy has a point. I thought back to my earlier days when I rode a conventional bike, and tried to imagine how I would feel if my favorite trails were suddenly invaded by hordes of these new fangled e-bikes. It's hard to be sure, but I might just feel the same way.