bob armani
Well-Known Member
Deeps ...
You have a challenge on your hands with best place to fit the bottle usurped by the battery! Both Fabric's and Fidlock's systems do address a real problem; however, I'd recommend Fidlock bottles more out of necessity than enthusiasm. Fidlock bottles are not robust (which is presumably why the advertising department had to rebrand them as now been supplied with 'Gravity Kits' - silly little strips of metal that are almost guaranteed to snap).
Top Tube:
Seat Tube:
- Anyway, suppose that you did have a Fidlock bottle where the battery is. To release it: twist clockwise with your right hand and lift (more difficult left-handed because the bottle's top would be turning away); to return it place the Fidlock bottle directly over the magnetic studs and let it be grabbed. That's straightforward.
- Now imagine doing that with the Fidlock bottle under the top tube (C-D). Far too difficult, I think. I'd prefer a Fabric in that position or a conventional bottle carried in a side-release cage such as the Arundel Sideloader or Topeak Dualside. The Topeak X-15 swivel mount might also help.
- There is of course the radical alternative: put the bottle cage on top of the top tube. Inelegant practicality?
Leaking:
- On my Trek Powerfly 5 eMTB, I use an Arundel Sideloader on the seat tube (A-B) but only for a medium size tool keg from Zefal. It's difficult to remove but that is hardly an everyday problem.
- Fidlock now have a 450 mL bottle for tight spaces. It is not simply 25% smaller; it appears to be fatter and is, therefore, decidedly shorter. Worth a try - especially as it doesn't come fitted with a Gravity Kit.
... David
- I've just done an impromptu test by half-filling three water bottles and then shaking them up (with the drinking valves open) over the kitchen sink!
- Camelbak Jet Wave (high quality but by far the cheapest of the three): not a drop escaped.
- Fabric: some spillage.
- Fidlock: more spillage.
Informative post here. Fidlock's systems sounds a lot like the SKS Monkey Link system.