[#8] X52.. Water Bottle holders..Torque Washers.. Step-Over Frame modification.

Sic Puppy

Active Member
[#8] X52.. Water Bottle holders..Torque Washers.. Step-Over Frame modification.
I thought that I'd go ahead and post this thread because it has some ideas which may be of interest to any ebike owner. You really need to 1st scroll down to the end of this post to examine the photo's. Things will then make more sense.
a). Water Bottle holder: As you may already know, water bottle holder placement on the frame of any ebike can be quite a challenge, and on these moped-style frames, even more so. I stumbled upon this method of fastening 1 or 2 units to pretty much any ebike.
I had already installed this handlebar height extender https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07V3X23ZB/ref=sspa_dk_detail_4? and, as a side benefit, thanks to the multiple shims (3 or more), I was able install 2 of these water bottle holder brackets (1 black and 1 red) in place of 2 of those shims. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08RBWC43B/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o09_s00?ie=UTF8&th=1
Upon inspecting my 6 ebikes, every one of them has at least a couple of (spacer) shims under the stem. The aforementioned bottle holder bracket(s) are exactly the same width as those shims. Thus, the bracket will just replace the shim(s), as needed. You only need to verify that the side location of the bottle holder won't interfere with side-to-side movement (hit the top tube/bar) when you turn the handlebar.
Once you have the bracket(s) located in a good position, it is time to screw on/attach the water bottle holder to the skinny little bracket. Since I already own these water bottle holders (2 for $11-- not bad) https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07CZWQYD7/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&th=1 they were my logical choice.
Also needed is 1 (or 2) of this particular item: https://www.amazon.com/Progresso-Tr...wder-18-5-Ounce/dp/B00434J53M/ref=sr_1_1_sspa? Why a can of PROGRESSO soup? Because its fatter than normal width (for a soup can) makes it an ideal container in which to insert a typical size water bottle. And, just for you to use as a reference, I actually use this water bottle (among others) https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B093FJW45Q/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1 on numerous occasions and it works just fine. Of course, the shorter water bottles work great, too.
There are a few pre-assembly modifications needed to make this set-up work correctly.
Having the empty soup can, with its pop-top lid off, means that you need to also use a regular can opener to remove the thin sharp rim edge left by the pop-top. Now is also a good time to “personalize” the soup can by removing the original label and applying whatever pattern rocks yer boat. I used contact paper carbon fiber and a 1” strip of multi-color cloth trim.
You might assume that all you need to do now is insert the soup can into the bottle holder, insert the water bottle itself, and you are Good To Go. Not so, young grasshopper. There will be 2 things working against you:
The weight of a full water bottle.
Gravity.
What you now need to do is use a flat blade screwdriver and a hammer to make 2 parallel slits/slots (about 1/4” apart) in the bottom of the soup can (think snake fangs). Now look at the photo of the linked black water bottle holder(s). See how, at the bottom, there is that small “L”? Well, there are also 2 open slots down there. What you need to do is get a ZipTie and run it through the soup can slits and also both of those bottom slots. Doing so will prevent the soup can from being ejected from the holder. However, that, in and of itself ,will only ½ solve the problem.
You will also need to locate a stretchy elastic band-type item (I actually bought these-- they work great) https://www.amazon.com/Revlon-Extra-Black-Elastics-Count/dp/B01F8SRBXC/ref=sr_1_32? This stretchy thing will be inserted along the top edge of the water bottle holder and then wrapped around the water bottle body/top section as needed to prevent “ejection”.. Works like a champ. EasyBreezy.. And there you have it. As a side benefit, you can use the soup can/container to act as a kind of mini-storage compartment. I actually put my keys in one and then set a water bottle on top of the keys to keep them from being ejected.

b). Torque Washers:[This next section, while being useful info all rear hub motor ebike owners, is especially pertinent to owners of the moped-style hot rods using 20” size wheels because those lil' beasts have torque/power output getting to the ground ALOT quicker when compared to the Big Beast 26” fat tire ebikes.]
Anyone who has had the opportunity to remove/install the rear wheel of a rear hub motor ebike is familiar with the uniquely shaped washer (s) with an oblong (instead of round) hole and a “tit”. It is called a TorqueWasher and its intended use is to prevent the powerful rear hub motor from twisting the axle within the dropouts. Should a person forget/prefer to not use these specific-use items, the eventual result will be that the entire axle rotates within the dropouts and all those wires (9, I believe) coming from the rear hub axle will be ripped right out of the hub. You will then be left with an ebike turned multi-thousand dollar clothing rack.
I recently read about a fellow ebiker who either forgot or neglected to utilize this washer, ripped out all the wiring, rounded out the oblong dropouts, and is now having an extended wait for the eventual delivery of a new rear wheel/rear motor unit. Damn. Talk about a tough lesson learned. Anyway, along those accident-preventative lines, I have stumbled across these items:
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/3256801933528894.html?spm=a2g0o.order_list.0.0.45ae1802u8zhm1
I went ahead and ordered the 16mm set of 2. I wasn't sure which size is the best fit, but I figure that, if a little “wiggle room” results from using 16mm instead of 14mm, I can live with that. Surely the axle won't be able to rotate 360 degrees. They should be here in a few days.
As far as having a correct/proper location for the smaller “not axle” slot, I'm only concerned about having something (a fat washer/nut,etc) between the frames chain/seat stay to limit the movement of the special torque washer. I'm hoping/intending to leave the (2) original torque washers in place and then use this new item as a replacement for the regular (round) washers. Time will tell. You can never be too cautious.
UpDate: I ordered the oblong/rectangular 16mm items on Aug 24th. They arrived today, Sept. 9th, from China. I installed one washer on the disc brake side of the X52rear axle. There was a certain amount of “wiggle room”, but not near enough to spin the 16mm torque washer. Also, while the provided screws/nuts were totally incorrect (size-wise), the smaller hole aligned perfectly with one of the screw holes already on the frame dropout. I just had to find a correctly sized bolt. I would recommend that, if you do order this item, order the oblong/rectangular 14mm combo instead, regardless of the model of rear hub motor ebike that you own (see the following sentence)..
I also tried this 16mm washer on the rear axle of my 2019 M2S(brand) R750(model) rear motor hub (BaFang 750 watt) fat tire beast. It easily spun completely around. So, I went ahead and ordered the oblong/rectangular 14mm washer combo for 2 reasons: 1). to see how tight the fit on the X52 rear axle will be and, 2), to see if the 14mm unit(s) will be an acceptable fit (maybe just a little wiggle room) on the M2S ebike(s)-- remember, I own 2 of those.
If things work out as expected, I'll just leave the one 16mm washer on the X52 and install one of the 14mm washers on the disc brake side of each of the M2S fat tire beasts rear axle. I'll post an UPDATE addendum to this post when those items arrive and are checked out.
By the way, as far as “quality control” is concerned at ArielRider: The nuts on the FRONT suspension fork axle are 18mm.. The nuts on the REAR motor axle are 22mm. Duh on someone..


c). StepOver Frame modification: I have mentioned in a few of my previous X52 postings that my 30” leg is put to its full outward extension whenever I mount/dismount from my mighty steed (with its mail box modified 39” high seat height). After much thought, I have decided that I am just going to go ahead and REMOVE the “(dual) top tube”. Thus, I will then have a Step-THRU X52 beast. I don't think that the structural integrity will be compromised. As for the open exposed ends of the cut off top tube, I will insert handlebar end plugs in every hole(4).
I already own a step-thru ebike (from a 3rd rate company located in a 3rd world country) and, after careful examination, I believe that my X52 can handle the modification with no problem at all. After all, my riding consists of 99.9% paved bike paths/sidewalks,etc.-- no fancy smancy off road stuff for me. Besides, in regards to other ebikes: I have seen many step-thru designs that use extra bracing-type tubes for frame reinforcement. I have also seen other frames that use no such “extra assistance”. In both cases, I have also seen some rather large mammals astride these ebikes, and all seems to be fine and dandy. If, by chance, a situation does arise whereas I've discovered that the modification was a “duh” idea (crack in the frame, etc), I will either a). re- connect the removed top tube pipes via short steel inserts or, b). insert solid steel rods (from HomeDepot) the entire length or, c). go to a local Metal Fabrication shop and have them weld a re-enforced metal strip along the bottom of the down tube (where the X52 battery is attached) of the frame. Either way. EasyBreezy. A piece of cake.
TaaDaa. I'll see how things go.
Thats all for now..
 

Attachments

  • FILE0004 (4).JPG
    FILE0004 (4).JPG
    158.7 KB · Views: 409
  • FILE0005 (4).JPG
    FILE0005 (4).JPG
    325.3 KB · Views: 387
  • FILE0027.JPG
    FILE0027.JPG
    402.8 KB · Views: 390
  • FILE0034.JPG
    FILE0034.JPG
    410.5 KB · Views: 418
  • FILE0043.JPG
    FILE0043.JPG
    276.6 KB · Views: 401
Last edited:
A water bottle holder is a device or accessory designed to hold and carry water bottle label holder. It can be made of various materials such as plastic, metal, or fabric, and can be attached to backpacks, bicycles, or belts. The purpose of a water bottle holder is to allow the user to carry a water bottle conveniently, especially when engaging in outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, or backpacking.
 
"StepOver Frame modification:
I don't think that the structural integrity will be compromised.
I've discovered that the modification was a “duh” idea"

You will destroy the mechanical integrity of your frame if you remove the top supports, they are there for a reason.
Even if you add a brace

"weld a re-enforced metal strip along the bottom of the down tube"

It will never be a strong as the stock frame.

Your frame will break when you are doing 25 mph and hit a bump, then.......

Bottom line----

DON'T DO IT.

Sell the bike you have and buy a proper step thru frame bike.
 
Hi, Welcome to EBReview..
That is definitely sound advice for sure.
I have decided that my best option is to just leave the frame as is and go ahead and make sure that I always have ready access to a curb, a rock, etc. when it comes to mounting/dismounting. That seems to be working okie-dokie so far. I really only need about a 1.5" high "step" to be able to safely corral my X52 mailbox beast.
 
My two cents, do not saw the frame!
All those water bottle carriers seem like you're going on an expedition, and in that case why not just have a couple of solid rear rack panners that will hold all your water, food hiking gear rain jackets shoes socks extra batteries you name it that's what panners are for keep your bike clean and clutter free. That makes it less of a target for the would be bike Thief! Just my two since not trying to offend.
 
My two cents, do not saw the frame!
All those water bottle carriers seem like you're going on an expedition, and in that case why not just have a couple of solid rear rack panners that will hold all your water, food hiking gear rain jackets shoes socks extra batteries you name it that's what panners are for keep your bike clean and clutter free. That makes it less of a target for the would be bike Thief! Just my two since not trying to offend.

Hi JoeDirt,
Welcome to the most excellent EBR website forums.
Thanks for your input on the water bottle set-up. I actually rely on this visual display, as mounted on the ebike, to show fellow ebikers, in an actual interaction, how to better manage their own ebikes' cockpit dashboard/sitting area.

Every time I encounter another rider who is aboard a step-thru frame ebike with a water bottle mount installed on the top of the top/down tube, or on the front section of the seat tube, I ask the obvious question: “Doesn't the location of your water bottle setup completely cancel out the benefits of the step THRU (as opposed to a step OVER) frame?”
Without exception their response is “Yes!”.
I then show them my configuration and also explain its logic. The “logic” being that everything is right there in front of you, yet it is also absolutely tucked out of the way. The X52 (see photos above) has 2 bottle mounts. I used actual water carrying bottles for the photos. In reality, the long orange bottle is replaced by a “half water bottle”. If you were to look at the ½ bottle, it seems to be a water carrying bottle (top nipple, etc). In realty, if you lift it up, you will find that the bottom ½ is gone. It is actually a stealth “glove compartment” for my ebike battery key and a multi-tool hex wrench unit.

Since my usual daily ebike ride is 50 miles, I carry 2 (or, 3 in the case of my peas o' chit X52 ebike) batteries. That being the case, I swap out batteries at the 25-mile point. To swap those batteries I MUST have my battery mount key with me. Thus, the fake small water bottle glove compartment.
The key is attached to a wire-retractable fob. So, I never forget to bring my battery key. I also don't have to worry about it falling out of the glove compartment and/or getting lost. Each of my 4 main ebikes have this same key/bottle installation.

I also own a 2023 M2S(brand) AllCargo(model)ebike https://shop.m2sbikes.com/products/all-go-cargo.
It has 3 stem mounted water bottle cages displayed. When I decided to buy a cargo-style ebike, I also decided I would overload it with extra add-on items (of my invention) to the extent that it would basically be the ebike equivalent of an SUV-- like a Toyota 4Runner.I have basically morphed that newest cargo ebike into a rolling visual demonstration model of the multitude of options available for any/all ebike riders to adapt to their own ebike beast-- be it the aforementioned 3 water bottle mount location, the use of an actual mailbox in lieu of a rear basket, the use of a small bathroom wastebasket in lieu of a front basket, how to attach side-mount tennis racquet/pickleball paddle holders, etc.
Or even the installation of a double front chainring (58 teeth/46 teeth) to a). double their gearing from 7-speed to 14-speed, etc .and, b).eliminate “ghost pedaling” (did the chain fall off?) as is the case for use of a 58teeth chainring.
In other words, a practical visual display is worth a thousand words in conveying the items intended purpose.

As for me, at age 73, my only desire with any/all of my 6+ ebikes is The DailyRide. I don't use them for anything else (going camping/extended journeys,etc.). However, that doesn't mean that my lil' peanut brain is not working overtime in regards to “thinking outside the box” to improve my/your/everyones inter-actions with their particular ebike beast. Thus, my multitude of thread postings on this EBR website.
Case in point: using actual motorcycle tires on my two 20” fat tire equipped ebikes. Both of my so-equipped ebikes are currently at10,000+ miles of same tire usage AND those motorcycle tires still have more tread than the original equipment bicycle tires that came installed on my (and on every other 20” fat tire equipped ebike) ebikes. As for extra tire weight: My AllCargo ebike gets 40 miles per battery, even though I usually only use 25-30 miles per battery per ride. But, its nice to know that I can indeed go for 80 miles if I desire.
SideNote:I have not had an ebike flat tire since Oct. 2018. It is now Dec. 2024. That data encompasses 6 ebikes in total. I ride to ride.. No flats.. No mechanicals..
Too much fun.

As for your pannier side mount suggestion: My personal setup makes panniers impractical. I live in a 4th floor condo. The building elevator is just a little too small to accommodate the bulkiness of a filled side pannier setup. That being the case, my use of the rear/top mounted mailbox actually works out perfectly-- on-bike storage for 1(or even 2) 18”long extra batteries without the overall too wide dilemma involving panniers.
Also, the entrance to my condo unit requires me to roll an ebike halfway thru the front door entry, then grab the bike and rotate the rear end a few inches to avoid the pedal from striking the interior wall. Just goes to show you that it's always gonna be something.

I actually have 3 new EBR threads (1 for the peas o' cit X52, and 2 for the AllCargo beast) needing to be completed. However, with abundant pleasant riding weather being the current case, I will probably wait until I'm snowed in for 3 days until I actually begin pounding the keys for those threads.
 
Back