specialized Como 4.0 chain vs specialized Como 4.0 Belt IGH, which is the way to go?

[Blakeman62]

Just wondering if one is better than the other?
Can you please list the pros and cons of these two.
Thank you in advance for your thoughts.

 

[Stefan Mikes]

These two models are almost identical. Here are the main differences for the IGH version compared to the chain version:

• It is heavier than the chain version
• It is more expensive than the chain version
• It requires no maintenance (the chain version requires the drivetrain maintenance)
• It requires operating a twist shifter (no problem for most of riders). The chain version has a traditional click shifter
• It is less efficient than the chain version, and a worse climber than the chain version
• It hardly allows any gear ratio modification
• It is harder to remove the rear wheel of the IGH e-bike for a field repair of a flat than it is with the chain version.

As the IGH version of Como is decidedly a city e-bike, I would recommend it to riders who do not want to do more to their e-bike than occasional tyre re-inflation, unless there are very steep hills around, and somewhat bigger weight (3 lb) and price are not a deal breaker.

 

[scrambler]

It depends on your background and preference.

If you are a traditional biker and love your derailleurs, then stick with what you like and are familiar with.

If you are a traditional biker that never really cared for the maintenance, adjustments, grease, inability to shift at stand still of a derailleur, or if you are new to bikes in general and appreciate simplicity and comfort, then definitely go for the IGH