I really don’t like the way the full fenders look, they work only if they wrap all of the way to back of tire. Any shorter they will sling mud up onto your rack ( if you have one) and if too short ( which most are) you’ll end up with mud and water on your back. I make a flat fender out of ABS plastic 4” wide and around 42” long and attach it with neatly done zip ties and drillEd holes (in plastic) to the bottom of rack and use existing bolt hole(s) in front. It doesn’t look dorky like a full fender does and works great. By the way, you need a rack for this to work.