This thread is suddenly relevant for me. One of the pedals on my 13 month old (2500 miles) Ultimate T10+ wore out as well. This is notable because it's the first thing that's malfunctioned on the bike since I had it, I haven't even had a flat tire. Another odd thing is that my bike came with a second set of pedals, the bike shop had no idea why and perhaps they were included in error. Sadly I gave those away so now I'm looking. Probably a nice flat MTB style pedal with a good grip is the way to go--my #2 fear while biking is having a foot slip off the pedal. I like that the Raceface pedals come in colors, I'm wondering if I want to match or contrast with the shiny red paintjob on the bike.